After hearing Emily Scott Robinson's movingly sung "The Time For Flowers" on Community Radio St. Louis's "Backroads" show yesterday, I sought out other clips from her "Appalachia" recording. One standout track from her January release, in addition to "...Flowers," is her cover of the traditional folk tune, "The Water Is Wide."
Mary Black and Niamh Parsons sing two of my favorite versions of "...Water...," but I have yet to hear a subpar rendition. Duncan Wickel and Robinson blend well vocally, and their subtle guitar and violin shadings enhance the melody appropriately. Lyrically, the tune is idealistic and bittersweet--qualities readily apparent in Robinson's and Wickel's vocals.
I'm not surprised that "The Water Is Wide" has survived in so many incarnations for centuries. Its lyrics are universally relatable and timeless, and instrumentally, the melody is too heartfelt to be denied.