On this first Sunday of Advent, my thoughts have turned to "O Come, O Come, Emmanuel," a hymn we sang in church frequently in the four weeks before Christmas. I have yet to hear any radio station play the Karla Bonoff and Michael McDonald rendition of it. Granted, "...Emmanuel" has a more downcast, solemn feel than most carols, making it difficult for pop stations to segue it with other Christmas tunes.
The contrast in vocal stylings might also be a factor. Bonoff sings her verses with tasteful understatement. McDonald, though, doesn't hold back. I'm not critical of either approach because those styles suit each artist best. Even if you're extremely familiar with McDonald's powerful pipes as a lead and backing singer, it's still a shock to hear him come roaring in for the first time during "...Emmanuel." During an interview, Bonoff said that McDonald's voice blew out a microphone during their recording sessions. I believe it, and I'm not critical of that. When you have a voice that commanding, it's understandable that you'd use it fully.
This Christmas season is still young, so maybe, I'll hear at least one station play it--and possibly segue it with Steve Winwood's "Christmas Is Now Drawing Near At Hand."