While ranking my favorite songs of 2016 and 2018, I marveled at what a bumper crop of well-crafted tunes had been released and considered expanding my countdown to 30 or more songs. 2025, in contrast, is not that type of year. However, every year has its share of compelling music, so here are my rankings for this year--subject to change five minutes from now:
25. Spine Oil-Samia (This rhythmically appealing April release's forthright
lyrics show that the protagonist is more strong-willed than people
realize.)
24. Nothing I Need-Lord Huron (This March release's roots rock underscoring
punctuates honest admissions about not being able to pinpoint exactly
what you want out of life.)
23. Riders Of The Moon-Arc De Soleil (The guitar underscoring the vocals reminds me of early '70s, Bob Welch-era Fleetwood Mac.)
22. Better Broken-Sarah McLachlan (Sound
lyrics about the pain and wisdom that come from making mistakes.)
21. B61-The Westerlies (I never expected to hear Aoife O'Donovan's
thoughtfully written song about isolation transformed into a brassy jazz
instrumental, but it translates more successfully than I would have
expected.)
20. Boom-Sierra Hull (Vocally and instrumentally, this is a different style
than I'm used to hearing from Hull. It's successful, in part because
rhythmically, the melody reminds me of Nilsson's "Coconut.")
19. Hymn-Nicholas Krolak (Krolak sustains a catchy bass riff for over nine
minutes while the trumpeter and guitarist take off on flights of fancy.)
18. Ventura Highway-Dw3 featuring Peter White (Vocally and instrumentally, the group nails the essence of America's most pleasant hit. By
slowing down the tempo just a tad, emphasizing White's guitar playing,
and giving the tune some smooth jazz and R&B gloss, this ensemble
puts its own spin on the song without compromising the original
version's appeal.)
17. Metal-The Beths (Dry scientific facts, made bouncy and palatable. They Might Be Giants isn't the only group capable of such a feat.)
16. Hummingbird Highway-Dar Williams (This lyrically thought-provoking track makes the listener realize that when we're kids, we don't always
understand or appreciate the long hours and dedication that having a
job, especially one that requires being away from one's family for long
stretches, requires.)
15. Moonlight In Vermont-Cyrus Chestnut (Chestnut plays a subtle, classy, unhurried rendition on the piano, and
it's one of many standout tracks on his "Rhythm, Melody, And Harmony"
release. Also recommended: "Autumn Leaves.")
14. UtopiaNoah-Nathan East & Noah East (Sublime jazz piano and bass.)
13. Kwiczoly-Klawo (Appealingly spacey keyboard.)
12. Energy-Josh Meader, Matthew Thomson & Alex Hirlian (A cool, dramatic, news bulletin-style melody.)
11. Cherry Tree-Lera Lynn (This type of acoustic guitar accompaniment
flatters Lynn's alto voice well, and this May release has refreshingly
candid lyrics questioning whether one has made the right choices in
life. It's a good reminder to seize the day before too much time passes.)
10. Feeling-Billie Marten (This is one of 2025's low-key charmers, with its lo-fi vocals and acoustic instrumentation. Also recommended: "Planets.")
9. Anywhere-Ratboys (Upbeat indie rock with power pop sensibilities,
released in advance of the band's 2026 album, "Singin' To An Empty
Chair." Julia Steiner's voice captures the zeal of someone
who wasn't ready to pursue someone but is all in now. The lyrics don't break new ground, but the energy level is captivating, and the tune has a strong hook, so it would feel wrong not to place it in the top 10.)
8. Money Hits-Daughter Of Swords (A catchy, chirpy way of imagining how life will get easier when your ship comes in.)
7. Van Nuys-Dan Wilson (A brief, thoughtful new age piano piece fit for a farewell. The last chord
reverberates effectively, letting the farewell vibe linger. This is one of the subtler compositions in this year's rankings, and it deserves credit for bringing aspects of Beethoven's sonatas to mind.)
6. Dinorah Dinorah-Butcher Brown (Released in March, this is a strong
rendition of an Ivan Lins tune. George Benson covered it previously in a
slightly faster tempo. Brown's version retains the essence of
the tune's Brazilian flavor while modernizing it.)
5. Long Pond Lily-Hayden Pedigo (One of this year's most pleasant guitar melodies. When the tempo picks up, it reminds me of one of my favorite guitar pieces, Ken Bonfield's "From A Friend.")
4. Pups-Lemon City Trio (Forthright trumpet over a Pat Metheny-style backdrop.)
3. Ancient Light-I'm With Her (Compelling vocal harmonies, as usual, from Sarah Jarosz, Sara Watkins, and Aoife O'Donovan. Lyrically, this is a nice reminder that while you may think your problems are unique, they're typically universal, and previous generations have weathered comparable storms.)
2. Slice, Diced, And Fried Twice-The Lewis Express featuring Chip Wickham (If I hadn't known otherwise, I would have sworn this was a Herbie Mann recording from the '60s or early '70s. The piano and flute carry "Slice, Diced, And Fried Twice," in a melody
that sounds to me like "Pata Pata" mingling with "One Mint Julep.")
1 Ifyoucall-Parcels (This track, released in September, sports one
of 2025's catchiest rhythms, a strong guitar hook, solid vocals, and a
'70s dance influence. The vocals and instrumentation pull off the
tricky-to-navigate task of sounding contemporary yet old school.
Lyrically, this is as sound a way as any to remind someone, "I'm the
cavalry.")
So, that's how things panned out in 2025. Here's hoping my favorite tunes next year aren't so arduous for me to rank.