Thanks to YouTube, I've heard the generous assortment of alternate takes on the newly expanded "A Charlie Brown Christmas" soundtrack. Although I think the renditions on the original edition are still the best ones, these are some interesting different versions:
- Christmas Is Coming (#5, Take 1) (September 17, 1965) (At the 1:54 mark, there's more prominent bass and more freewheeling piano improvisation from Guaraldi. As a result, the middle section has a slower, slyer walk of a melody than usual.)
- Christmas Is Coming (#1, Take 2 and #1, Take 7) (September 21, 1965) (It's interesting hearing a different middle section that continues the already established theme in a different key. When Guaraldi made that transition, I envisioned a plane taking off.)
- Christmas Time Is Here (Vocal) (#1, Take 4 and #1, Take 5) (It's endearing hearing this familiar piano backdrop with guide vocals instead of finished lyrics.)
- Greensleeves (Take 6, Take 7) (October 28, 1965) (I was startled to hear "What Child Is This?" as a mambo, but it works.)
- Skating (#3, Take 3) (September 17, 1965) (If you're a drummer who thinks brushes are underused, this version is for you.)
- Skating (#7, Take 1) (September 22, 1965) (A faster tempo and a punchier arrangement.)